February 9, 2015

When Adoptive Family Members Say They Support Your Search But Really Don't

Decades ago, I made it known that I was searching for my natural family. At the time, all of my adoptive  family with whom I had a conversation about it  said they were supportive.  In some cases, that was true. In others, it was not.

I heard: "I support you all the way" or "I support you 100%."

Regarding my search, they did appear to support me. As time went on, I realized that as long as I was searching for strangers who I would one day refer to as acquaintances, or friends – all was fine. But the moment I actually called them family, the support stopped. One adoptive family member in particular reiterated whether passive aggressively or outright, their "exclusive" position in my life. 

I’ve discovered, some are alright with you searching, as long as you don’t find family. As long as you don't find someone who is a motherfather, sister or brother…it’s okay. As long as your natural family referred to by their first names,  all is well. But as soon as you start referring to these folks as your family, as mom or dad -- or Lord forbid you start inviting them to your significant family events (birthdays, etc.) or sharing holidays -- look the heck out! Even Chuck Norris would be afraid.

My little sister, Kim, has just announced to the world that she is searching for her natural family. 

I can't help but wonder...has anything changed?

I am anticipating the future for her, and truly supportive of her in this by every definition possible. I will pray my guts out that she finds her natural family and they are receptive to her. 

She is already getting the declarations of support.  I am hopeful things will be different for her, regarding some adoptive family members. But I can’t help but wonder…do these declarations of support only extend to her search for acquaintances or new "friends"? Or is this "support" unqualified, 100% support for however she decides to relate and interact with her natural family? Will there be that same support from everyone when she may decide to refer to two individuals on the planet as, “Mom”? Will the declaration of support change if it means that things like Christmas or birthdays now involve people who were never there before, or (gasp!) the adoptive family has to actually learn to share???

My prayer is that this declared support is not just lip service, but truly without limitations. I hope she has freedom to call the shots without being called to task on anything or being asked to bend to someone else's desires. It’s her search, and her reunion to live out. I hope to God she can walk this journey in an atmosphere of true support and not one tainted by the insecurities and jealousies so often present when adoptees find family.
[Deanna drops the mic.]

*I received Kim's blessing prior to publishing this blog post. She loved it and also gave me the photos to post with it.

Comments (24)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Hopefully for your sister's sake...things have changed!!! People have learned from past mistakes, and grown.... I encountered some of this from some extended family members, one aunt in particular said something like "why would she want to search?? Why Now??"
When I got the opportunity to talk to her in person, I pointed out that doing her Genealogy projects where important to her...WHY wouldn't it be important to me?? Annoying. I got to the point that for those who wanted to stay in my life...would get onboard with it, or get out....
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
I hope for her sake that things have changed too. I don't want her to have to go through what I did.
Kim is fortunate to have her big sister on her side! I have my doubts that the jealousies will ever go away when we are dealing with closed adoption. My mother grins and bears it and I can talk to her about it, but she will never "like it". She was told by the adoption agency I was HER child -- and one of her biggests fears was my natural family coming back to re-claim me. I guess she just didn't think I might try to reclaim them! Good luck to your sister Kim!
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
I hear you, Lynn. People forget, we have a choice when we grow up, and many of us decide to take it. Adoptees with choices...whodathunkit???
:) you spoke my heart! I'm by nature a people pleaser & was raised by people who are not. Neither way is wrong but it causes me to second guess my right to form relationships however I feel comfortable doing it. I don't want to make my adoptive family uncomfortable (they will let me know if I do) but I have found commonality & connection that I've never known before with my birth families. I love all sides of my families & thankful to be loved and accepted by the majority of them. I just wish other people wouldn't find reasons to be offended, after all, we all have two sides to families (paternal/maternal) and seldom do relatives get offended by referring to the other side of the family as "family." Why be offended by a multi-faceted family as opposed to a two-sided one? Anyway, prayers for your sisters search, and thanks for your post!!!!
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
Such a great point, Sheila: "Why be offended by a multi-faceted family as opposed to a two-sided one?"

Great point. But unfortunately most individuals will go by FEELING and not FACT, as you have so eloquently stated.
Ah, Deanna. All I can say is hugs to you and your sister.
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
Thank you for the hugs. <3 Hugs back
Deanna, I've been incredibly blessed with both of my families. They mutually accept one another, and I refer to my original mother as "Mom" right in front of my adoptive mother without quarrels or hurt feelings. My adoptive father seems to be somewhat anxious, but getting over it. After all, my original father is dead, so he has no risk of losing me to another man, another father.

I pray that this is the case for Kim.
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
I pray so too, Becki. I so want things to be good for her.
Ann Philips's avatar

Ann Philips · 556 weeks ago

I will keep Kim in my prayers that all goes as she desires. My family claim to support me but I then with hold information from me. They give me little hints that they know something but won't tell me the info. I don't understand how you claim to support but withhold information. It is like they are protecting the dead, adopted mother died in 82. I was told that they did not want me to feel differently about her. In my thinking support is support, not only when things are going one way. Miss you writing here in your blog Deanna.
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
Thank you Ann. It means a lot.

I don't understand that either. Withholding is NOT support in any way shape and form! Unfortunately people DO protect the dead! Family secrets are DEADLY in themselves.

Love you
I have so much hope for Kim! Best of luck to her in her search…she has a great support in you.

My first thought is that kids don't come with any guarantees…how they behave and feel and what they do is solely up to them. I feel as though many adoptive parents feel like adoptees come with some kind of guarantee that we won't ever do anything to hurt their feelings and if we do there will be something said about it.

In therapy what I have learned is that my parents feelings belong to them…I am not responsible. If I had a sold, loving, unconditional relationship with them none of my searching would matter. But for me personally I don't have that at all. That's just how it goes, sad as it is. If I had that I would have been up front about my searching.

Adopted people have to come home to themselves at a certain point…to be self-loving and practice self-care for our OWN benefit…
3 replies · active 556 weeks ago
Agree, agree, agree, Lee H. Wise words.
"In therapy what I have learned is that my parents feelings belong to them…I am not responsible. If I had a sold, loving, unconditional relationship with them none of my searching would matter."

This is so very true, and we've spent a lot of time on it in my own therapy. One difference is that I was upfront about my search, and had that support. For the search. Things changed with reunion. The relationship I thought I had with my a/mom is not the relationship I actually have. There is a lot less room for me in it than I believed. Another thing to mourn.
My recent post fragments
I can totally relate to this. My adopted mom always claimed to be supportive and even said she would help me once I turned 18 if I wanted to search. I spent two years searching and didn't tell my adopted family until someone had actually been found and contact was about to be made with real live people. The same thing happened to me. Suddenly the support ended. When the topic of my reunion came up my adopted mom always clearly pointed out "she searched to know her medical history" and while that was technically true, it wasn't the main reason behind my search. Some of my birth family came to my adopted father's funeral which resulted in a lot of friends asking questions. She overheard me telling the story and referring to my birth mom as my mom. I caught her reaction out of the corner of my eye. She started crying over what I said but walked up to the casket and pretended she was crying over my dad. My reunion lasted six years and now I do not have contact with my birth family (long story). Since there was a falling out she feels it gives her the right to talk negatively about them, and she definitely has a hard time hiding the glee in her voice. You've actually reminded me of an important part of my story I haven't written yet!
My recent post Stifled Emotions
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
It never ceases to amaze me how similar so many adoptee stories are. That's all I'll say about that. :)
Helen Frost's avatar

Helen Frost · 556 weeks ago

I really wish that people would understand that your children, whether biological or adopted, come through you. They are not possessions!! Let go and let them live their journey!!
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
I so agree. Children are not possessions. Unfortunately the fact that they really CAN be bought and sold (and that adoption is a 13 BILLION dollar industry) make it hard to get that across. :(
Interesting and very true observation about the distinction between finding birth "people" and viewing them as family vs. just friends. I like to think that my sisters, cousins and I are both. My A-family has had over 20 years to make this adjustment. I think my A mom is finally learning to enjoy having all the "young folks" around! Paige
1 reply · active 556 weeks ago
Yes. As long as we just find people...we are alright.
It's been said numerous times, but it's worth repeating: Parents can love multiple children, so why can't children love multiple parents? If the relationship is secure, adoptive family shouldn't be threatened by the search for birth family.

When I reconnected with my birth sister in my 30's, my adoptive sister told me that she was worried I'd leave her behind. She then became defensive and closed-off, and eventually pushed ME aside -- thereby manifesting the very thing she'd been worried about.

I just don't get it.
My recent post Sent away -- again (part I).....
You always have a way of getting it "just right". I am an adoptee in reunion for over 20 years! My adoptive parents were supportive until my birth family became known by name. I remember sitting at a triad support group (back in the 90s) and the then wise psychologist said to my parents, "you are now (supportive), but will you be when she (birth mom) becomes real". Sure enough, my mom, especially struggled to make room for more family. I often feel like we are caught in a land of in between. I'm glad God reminds me I am His always and to keep building bridges. Thanks for all you do. I hope we can meet some day. Cheri

Post a new comment

Comments by